Corporate law concerns companies and business organizations — and the laws governing the association and functions of shareholders, directors, employees, creditors, consumers and the business community as a whole. Biswajit Sarkar advises on company structure and governance, foreign collaboration and investment, joint ventures, LLPs, mergers and acquisitions, and on resolving disputes through arbitration and conciliation.
Company law concerns companies and business organizations. Corporate law is the broader spectrum that encompasses the laws governing the association and the functions of shareholders, directors, employees, creditors, consumers and the business community as a whole. Its premise is that a corporation is described as a person in a political capacity, created by law, that endures in perpetual succession.
Different countries recognise various forms of business entity, such as:
Most of the companies run for non-commercial purposes. The members guarantee the payment of certain amounts in case the company goes into liquidation.
This type of company has shareholders with limited liability.
It can be a company with or without share capital, and does not enjoy limited liability where the company goes into liquidation.
India now has a liberalized economy, strong financial growth and a well-proven judicial system, and is a signatory of the WTO. The nation is now encouraging foreign investment in almost every sector, and the Indian economy is marching through an encouraging business scenario.
Specific industries having foreign investment of 50% and above are entitled to automatic approval by the R.B.I.
Corporate law is the analysis of legal and external affairs, such as mergers and acquisitions (M&A), and of how shareholders, stakeholders, consumers and other parties interact with one another, internally and externally, through corporate governance and commercial transactions.
The NCLT is a quasi-judicial body. It deals with corporate matters that are civil in nature and arise from the Companies Act, generally concerning registered companies in India. Earlier the Company Law Board was responsible for cases related to companies and factories; this responsibility has now shifted to the NCLT, which handles all cases related to listed companies in India. It functions on the rules set out in the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) and follows the guidelines laid down by the Central government.
The NCLT has the power to cancel the registration of any company if the registration was obtained by unlawful means under section 7(7) of the Companies Act. It can also freeze the assets of a company and restrict its functioning.
An investigation can be carried out against a company if 100 members order it through an application, a provision laid down by the Companies Act 2013. A person who is not part of a company can also persuade the NCLT to investigate in certain situations, and a complaint against abuse or mismanagement in the company can be filed under section 397 of the Companies Act.
A class action suit falls under section 245 of the Indian Companies Act and penalizes fraud. If a company cheats or steals money from its investors or shareholders, the NCLT may demand that the company compensate the victims. It can be filed against both private and public companies, but financial institutions like banks are exempted.
NCLT is responsible for converting a public limited company into a private limited company. As per section 459 of the act, the NCLT has the power to impose restrictions and conditions for such conversion.
The NCLT holds primary jurisdiction in insolvency and bankruptcy cases, where it accepts and analyses evidence from both creditors and debtors. The tribunal has benches in many cities, which reduces multiplicity of litigation in different courts and forums.
An order passed by the NCLT may be appealed before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT).
To meet the goals of a business, it is important to establish a management structure, so that investors can assign and divide tasks amongst the members and employees of the company. A company has various stakeholders — shareholders, directors, managers and officers — who together constitute its organizational hierarchy. Here is how each of them functions in managing a company.
Shareholders hold shares and have the right to share in the profits of the company. As they invest their capital, they are responsible for overseeing whether the company is well run and managed. They review the decisions of the board and express their objection or approval of the actions of the company's management.
Shareholders choose the board of directors to represent the interests of the company. The directors are considered the elected representatives of the shareholders and represent them at board meetings. While selecting a director, certain minimum requirements must be kept in mind (see below).
Within the directors, a Managing Director is selected who is responsible for the affairs of the company. With help from the other directors, they hire senior managers and other officers, which leads to a better functioning of the company.
The directors appoint the officers who hold various positions of responsibility in a company. The most popular positions are set out below.
Every manager in a company is given an area of work to handle. They must meet deadlines and make sure the teams under them function effectively, reporting to the officers or other senior managers in their division. Accounts manager, store manager and regional manager are some of the positions managers hold, and many are also responsible for managing resources such as people, financials and equipment.
The highest-ranking position in a company. A CEO handles all managerial decisions and oversees the daily operations of the company.
Second in command to the CEO, who reviews the business operations in the company.
A senior financial executive responsible for overseeing all financial activities of a company, including financial planning, raising funds, accounting and other related matters.
A senior marketing executive responsible for activities such as improving the brand of the company, advertising and managing marketing campaigns. The CMO oversees the sales, marketing and development teams to market the product and company more efficiently.
Corporate governance is a set of practices, policies and procedures that controls the way a company is controlled and directed. It deals with various stakeholders, including customers, management and governmental bodies and institutions. A company, while participating in any business activity, must adhere to the rules of corporate governance.
In India, the organizational framework for corporate governance consists of the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) and the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). SEBI handles the monitoring and regulating of corporate governance for the listed companies in India through Clause 49.
A company governed on sound principles must work efficiently and ensure compliance with all laws and guidelines. A disciplined company is ready for any uncertain events and has all the risk mitigation mechanisms in place.
Good corporate governance systems can improve shareholder satisfaction and the valuation of a company, through sustained efforts to keep the interest of all stakeholders intact. Even a single unlawful act can reduce the value of a company in the minds of shareholders — strong corporate governance policy must be the backbone of any company.
Sound corporate governance policies determine where the company stands compared to its competitors. Due to recent frauds and economic malpractices, many questions are raised on the way a company is governed. Governance lays the stepping stone for the character of the company by utilizing resources and corporate strategies efficiently.
During the merger and acquisition of a company, corporate governance determines a good deal from a bad one. Stakeholders value a company with good corporate governance set in place.
Corporate governance plays a vital role in the growth of any company. Bad governance can lower investors' trust and decrease a company's reputation among consumers, which may lead to severe economic downturns. Designing a solid corporate governance framework is no easy task, and it differs from industry to industry.
Foreign collaboration with Indian industrialists is now common, and is a typical way for MNCs to take part in Indian industry. For collaborations, Indian and foreign enterprises enter into international collaboration agreements — through the sale of technology, spare parts, and the usage of foreign brand names for final goods.
The authority who approves a financial collaboration is the Reserve Bank of India.
The Department of Industrial Development approves or disapproves any technical collaboration.
Since 1949, the government's approach has remained mostly unchanged: it allows foreign direct investment on a preferential basis in sectors that will be beneficial for the country. Foreign undertakings have to conform to the industrial policy of the country, and the same goes for Indian undertakings. Foreign investors are always treated on an equal footing with their Indian counterparts.
The earlier statute was intended to regulate foreign exchange.
The Act implemented by the government in place of FERA, with foreign exchange regulation as its goal.
The government must give approval to set up a foreign collaboration; approval is requested under the relevant foreign exchange laws in force, and the requisite Government policy is required. A foreign corporation may form a foreign collaboration, and it is not necessary to form a joint venture with an Indian partner. Where the minimum limit set out in the automatic route is exceeded, government approval is needed for a foreign collaboration.
A foreign investment promotion board has been established by the government to encourage foreign investment in India. The Board's responsibilities include:
Expediting the approval of proposals.
Reviewing the collaborations that have been approved.
Identifying and establishing contacts to invest in India.
Earlier, India's industries focused only on consumer items. Indian industry has benefited from foreign collaborations by diversifying its output range, across steel, light and heavy engineering, petroleum refineries and other industries.
Foreign Direct Investment has long been a significant source of non-debt financing, and contributed to India's economic development and financial growth. Companies from other countries invest in India to take advantage of lower wages and of one-of-a-kind investment incentives like tax breaks, among other things. It also entails acquiring technological expertise, and in the country where the foreign investment is made, it creates jobs.
Foreign capital continues to come into India, thanks to the Indian government's favorable regulatory framework, which has created a thriving economic environment. In recent times the administration has taken many steps, including loosening FDI restrictions in areas such as defense.
The government route is a path for foreign investments that involves the government. Foreign investors must take government approval for such routes.
The areas that fall under the automatic route to FDI do not demand government approval — foreign investors can invest without obtaining government clearance. Someone must review the amended regulations right before making investments, which eliminates any misunderstanding.
In another nation, the parent company implements the same business plan. The goods and services produced outside the company's home nation are often identical to those produced in its home country.
This foreign direct investment is a type of FDI in which exports are returned back to the home market. The expansion of trade blocs with low internal trade barriers but greater external trade barriers is the key contributor to this form of FDI.
Here, a company expands to another country with the goal of exporting the foreign country's output to a third country.
A joint venture is when two or more people pool their resources together to complete a particular task. The task can be anything business-related, even a project. Each person is liable for the profits, losses and so on. The joint venture is a separate identity, not related to the other business interests of the people associated. By nature, joint ventures are partnerships — any legal entity can come together to form one, including corporations, partnerships and limited liability companies, and even large companies may join hands with smaller companies to collaborate.
Before the talks of a venture are concluded, the partners undertake:
Identifying the companies or people who could be suitable partners for the venture.
Narrowing the field and ranking the candidates.
Inclusive of the due diligence of intellectual property, if any.
One firm may have well-established manufacturing operations while the other has better distribution channels. Together, a joint venture takes advantage of both their plus points, using the combined resources to fulfil the purpose of the venture.
Both companies benefit from the joint venture since they can leverage their production at a lower per-unit cost — especially true for high-cost technological developments. Advertising and labour expenses might also be cost-effective.
A joint venture between two companies or parties brings together diverse origins, knowledge and expertise. Each company stands to enjoy the other's expertise and skill.
A corporation may wish to expand its market into other nations and can profit from a joint venture agreement, supplying items to a local business and taking advantage of its market. Some countries refuse international companies from doing business there, which makes a joint venture the only way to enter a foreign market for those companies.
The joint venture agreement is an extremely essential document. It lays down the rights and obligations of the partners, the objectives of the venture, and — in detail — the initial contributions of the partners, the daily operations, responsibility for losses and right to profits. If drafted with care, it avoids litigation in future.
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) does not recognize the joint venture as such; the partnership formed between the two parties aids in the payment of taxes. If it is a separate entity, it will pay taxes like any other business or corporation. If it operates as an LLC, it will work in the same way as any other LLC would, with profits and losses passed through to the owners' personal tax returns. The joint venture agreement spells out the taxation of profits and losses — where the arrangement is a contractual relationship between the two parties, it is the joint venture agreement that divides up the tax between them.
An LLP combines the advantages of a corporation with the versatility of a partnership. It follows perpetual succession, and has the ability to form contracts and hold property in its own name. It is a separate legal entity with full liability for its assets. In a partnership firm the maximum number of partners cannot be more than 20. The agreement restricts each partner's liability only to their contribution, and no partner is liable for the activities of other partners who act without authorization.
There may be joint liability resulting from another partner's bad business decisions or misdemeanor. An LLP protects individual partners from such liabilities, while the LLP itself remains liable for its other duties as a separate business.
The agreement is tailor-made to fit every partner related to the LLP.
There is no restriction on the required amount of capital — an LLP can be established with a minimum amount.
An LLP only requires a minimum of 2 partners, and there is no maximum limit. It ranges from 2 to many.
The cost required to register an LLP is lower than for other forms of business.
There is no compulsion to audit the accounts of an LLP. Auditing is required only if the annual turnover crosses 40 lakhs, or if the contributions by the partners exceed 25 lakhs.
Limited liability partnerships have to file only two statements — the Annual Return and Statement of Accounts, and the Solvency Statement. A private corporation must accomplish at least eight to ten regulatory formalities and compliances.
The LLP is exempt from paying taxes on the income and share of its partners. The profits of an LLP can be taken by the partners, who are exempt from paying an additional tax in the form of DDT.
The internal governance structure of an LLP versus a joint stock corporation is a key distinction.
A company is regulated by law (i.e. the Companies Act, 1956).
An LLP is bound by a contract involving its partners.
Occasionally the phrases “mergers” and “acquisitions” are used identically, but their interpretations are separate. When one firm completely buys another, it is known as an acquisition. A merger is the coming together of two businesses to form a new legal entity under a single corporate name. It also helps in the valuation of a company — by examining similar companies in the industry and employing measures, a company can be reasonably evaluated.
A merger occurs when the boards of directors of two firms agree to merge and seek shareholder approval. The two businesses join hands and become a completely new legal entity.
In an acquisition, the purchasing corporation acquires a majority stake in the acquired company. It retains its identity and organizational structure.
By integrating core operations and eliminating previous organisational structures, consolidation creates a new corporation. Both companies' shareholders must approve the merger, after which they receive common equity shares in the new company.
One company offers to buy the other company's outstanding stock for a fixed price rather than the market price. The offer is made directly to the shareholders of the other firm by the purchasing company, going around the board of directors and management.
One business buys the assets of another company outright, and the shareholders must approve such a purchase. Asset purchases are common during bankruptcy proceedings, where other corporations compete for the bankrupt company's varied assets. The company is liquidated once the assets have been transferred to the purchasing businesses.
A management buyout is often referred to as a management-led buyout (MBO): the executives of one company buy a controlling stake in another, which makes it personal. Former executives frequently collaborate with a financier or former company leaders to assist in funding the deal. The majority of shareholders must approve such M&A transactions, which are often financed disproportionately with debt.
Their structures rely on the relation between the companies that enter into an agreement.
The two companies are fellow competitors. They share a common market.
A supplier merges with a company.
Two different companies that are not competitors, but serve the same consumer base.
Two different companies sell the exact same product, but in different markets. They may merge to expand their market reach.
In the same market, two companies sell different but related products.
Two companies with similarities between them may merge.
According to the Companies Act of 1956, the Memorandum of Association must allow the company to not only acquire but also continue with the activities of the acquired firm. If this is not included in the Memorandum of Association, authorisation from the shareholders, the Board of Directors and the Company Law Board must be requested.
The merger must be announced on the stock exchanges where the two firms are listed.
The High Court must accept the proposed merger, which has been approved by the board of directors.
The merger must be approved by a majority of shareholders and creditors.
After taking into account all of the grounds, the High Court should issue an order approving the merger. A certified copy of the order must subsequently be lodged with the Registrar of Companies.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) includes the mechanisms and dispute resolution techniques that act as a means for contesting parties to come to an agreement, just short of litigation.
Arbitration is a form of alternative dispute resolution in which the parties settle their disputes with the help of an outside party, without resorting to the legal system. After hearing both sides, the dispute is sent to a nominated person who makes a quasi-judicial decision on the issues. Because this is never a subject of public record, the procedure is kept private. When it comes to private conflict resolution, arbitration is one of the most successful and dependable methods. Arbitration can be done in two manners:
There is a dispute between the two sides and they are unable to resolve the problem amongst themselves. They agree to take their disagreement to a neutral arbitrator, whose verdict will be binding on both parties.
A process in which the parties are compelled to accept arbitration regardless of their willingness to do so. When one party in an industrial dispute feels affected by the other party's actions, the aggrieved party may request that the case be sent to any adjudication agency for resolution. The arbitrator, sometimes known as an arbitral tribunal, is a neutral person or persons charged with settling the issue the parties have brought before them.
Conciliation is a process of dispute resolution in which the disputants reach an agreement with the assistance of a conciliator. To reach an agreeable arrangement, the conciliator talks with the parties both together and separately. Reduced tensions, improved communications and other measures may be used to reach a final conclusion. It is a flexible process, allowing the parties to define the proceeding's content and purpose. It is risk-free, and the parties are not bound by it unless they sign it.
The practice of evaluating a brand's total financial value is known as brand valuation. If those who value a brand were also involved in its creation, there is a conflict of interest. To register a brand name, see our Trademark service section to know more about a trademark application.
When a firm wants to evaluate its assets and brand, brand valuation becomes critical.
The presence of the brand on the company's balance sheet demonstrates the actual return on assets.
Brand management becomes more effective if the brand is valued.
By treating the brand like any other asset, the company becomes less attractive to aggressive takeover bidders.
Brand value is particularly well suited to service sectors with few assets but a big number of clients.
This strategy is founded on the assumption that a branded product will sell more than one that is not. Premium refers to the difference in price between a branded and an unbranded good. When this premium is multiplied by the expected annual sales of the product, the outcome is an annual price premium, the sum of which equals the brand's worth.
This method involves deducting the profitability of the branded product that is accredited to tangible assets and other factors, leaving behind the value of the brand. In practice, however, it is difficult to attribute profitability to tangible assets and other factors.
This method determines the brand's value by calculating how much a third party would invest for the brand's use, or how much the owner saves by not paying for the brand's use.
To register your brand, prepare a trademark application with the specific documents: proof of registration of the business, the trademark in a soft copy format, a power of attorney signed by the applicant, and the brand logo image. Please refer to our Trademark service section to know more.
You must pay an application fee of Rs. 2500.
Fill out the brand name registration application, either manually or online. The receipt for e-filing is available immediately via the website.
The Registrar will evaluate the documents applied.
Indian Trade Mark Journals will publish the brand name. If there are no oppositions for 3-4 months after publication, the registrar considers it for acceptance.
If the registrar does not accept the registration, you may apply again, free of charge. However, if your application is rejected for a second time, you will have to start over.
Send us your queries and we'll get back to you.
Let's Talk