Beyond the core IP practices, Biswajit Sarkar advises on two fast-growing fields where intellectual property does the heavy lifting: Sports Law and Fashion Law. In both, trademarks, copyright, designs, patents and licensing turn creativity into a commercially productive asset.
India is famous for many things, majorly its cultural heterogeneity; however, of late its sports industry is taking the central ground. While India does not have specific legislations for sports law, it consists of an amalgamation of various different kinds of laws that affect athletes. Today, the sports industry is heavily dependent on intellectual property laws and cannot exist without the same.
There is no specific legislation in place for sports law in India yet. Majorly, it is covered under the Contracts Act, as it involves the player and the team they are signed under.
Every sport showcases some form of innovation and creativity. Without IP rights (especially trademark, patents and broadcasting rights), sports law cannot become a commercially productive asset. Without patent protection, technological advancement would not have been encouraged, and we would not have visualised today's improved athletic equipment.
Teams, leagues, manufacturers and so on are protected under the umbrella of our trademark laws. Licensing and merchandising agreements provide the funds needed to support the sports authority's development.
There are various authorities for sports in India, like SAI (Sports Authority of India), the National Sports Federations, and governing bodies of team sports like BCCI and the Indian Hockey Federation. It is the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports that formulates policies ensuring the regulation of sports in India.
Often called media rights, these rights under sports law are negotiated by the broadcasting organization for a commercial purpose. For example, this will include a sports-governing body or a film distributor showing that company's products on television or radio, either live, delayed or highlights.
Royalties earned by broadcasters from the sale of exclusive content to other media sources allow them to invest in the costly organisational and technical infrastructure required to broadcast sporting events to millions of fans across the world.
According to WIPO, broadcasters have exclusive protection for 20 years to authorise airing reruns, "fixation" (recording), reproduction, and public communication of their broadcasts under the 1961 International Convention for the Protection of Performers, Producers of Phonograms, and Broadcasting Organizations (Rome Convention).
Everyone agrees that the protection of broadcasters' rights needs to be updated in order to keep up with the digital communications revolution.
A person's personality rights are his or her right to control his or her own personality. This branch of sports law allows the personality to be protected as a person's property or under the right to privacy, and is divided into two categories: the Right to Privacy and the Right to Publicity.
Celebrities, including sports personalities, try to keep their personal lives and details as private as possible in order to avoid embarrassment in the public eye.
Publicity rights are the rights to utilise the value of a celebrity's popularity. Their fame, or popularity, is a strategy for increasing sales.
An individual may have the right of notoriety as a result of involvement in a particular event, sport, or film. That right, however, does not belong to the event that made the individual famous, nor to the corporation that organised the event.
Any attempt to transfer the right of publicity from individuals to the event organizer or a non-human organisation would violate Articles 19 and 21 of the Indian Constitution, under which no persona can be monopolised. A person's right of publicity belongs to him alone, and he is the only one who can profit from it.
If someone used Kapil Dev's or Sachin Tendulkar's name, persona, or indicia in relation to the World Cup without their permission, they would have a viable and enforceable cause of action.
Patents, designs and trademarks each play a distinct part in growing a sport, giving an event, team or piece of gear both an identity and commercial value.
Innovation in sports is the main factor that contributes to its growth and popularity among the masses. Innovative technologies protected by patents are taking sports to a whole new level. Smart sensors in sporting equipment enable athletes to track their performance, high-grade Wi-Fi networks in the stadium ensure fans are connected at all times, and newer technologies are helping athletes with disabilities hit record-breaking performances.
Aesthetics play a crucial role in sports. In a competitive sporting environment, the design gives a distinct identity to a sporting event, team or gear. It adds commercial value to the sport by appealing to consumers and making the sport more attractive.
A trademark is a sign capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one organization from those of others. It helps businesses build a reputation, is an important marketing tool, and can generate significant revenue. Manchester United, for instance, generates a large portion of its revenue through sponsorship deals and merchandise sales, which is only possible because of the loyalty of its fans and the power of the brand.
Fashion law, often known as apparel law, is a developing legal field that encompasses all aspects of a garment's product lifecycle, from design to brand security. It is an exponentially growing industry whose creations are protected under various IP laws, like Trademark, Copyright, Design, Patents, and so on.
Innovation and new ideas are the key aspects of fashion law, and hence IP protection and rights in the creation and marketing of products in the fashion industry is extremely important.
The owners of intellectual property earn money by licensing and assigning their products to third parties and collecting royalties. Licensing in fashion law improves the market's commercialization of intellectual property.
Copyright is a legal term that refers to the protection of unique literary or creative works. It focuses on the creative aspect of fashion design and excludes the physical utility. The design of the product, such as a print pattern, can be copyrighted, but the article of clothing cannot.
The provision governing copyright in designs registered or capable of being registered under the Designs Act, 2000 is section 15 of the Copyright Act. Under it, copyright does not exist in any design that has been registered under the Designs Act, which makes it apparent that copyright and design are intertwined.
Design, trademark and patent law each protect a different layer of a fashion product, and the industry leans on them in very different measures. As it evolves, so does the need for newer and better laws.
The Designs Act does not cover entire garments; rather, it protects the product's design, shape, colour and pattern, and the design should be registered under the Designs Act, 2000. The Act does not protect unregistered designs, and no one can sue for damages based on an unregistered design. The Copyright Act protects both registered and unregistered designs, as well as the rights of the design owner. From the date of registration, the design is protected for a term of ten years.
Signs, logos, quotes and symbols are all trademarked, and they are referred to as fashion brands. Because fashion patents are difficult to get, fashion corporations go to considerable measures to preserve their brands, opting instead for trademark protection. Trademark law in the fashion industry focuses on three things: it has to seem attractive enough to catch a consumer's attention; owning a particular trademark is beneficial to any business while getting revenues; and a trademark gives one a competitive advantage over the rest of the businesses in the market.
To capture consumers' attention in a crowded market, trademark owners must create products in a unique style or sell them in a variety of ways. They must register their items under trademark law in order to protect the brand, image, logo and sign of their products.
A creation must be valuable, unique and innovative in order to be patented. Patents may not immediately come to mind in the fashion sector, and because fashion trends change frequently, obtaining one is not worthwhile, and can be prohibitively expensive, unless a design can be duplicated year after year. A patent on a novel creation grants sole legal ownership and lets a corporation or creator safeguard its intellectual property rights.
India is far behind when it comes to regulating fashion, in comparison to countries like France or the USA. The rise of social media and online shopping has led to a greater need for more comprehensive fashion laws. It remains a niche area, but amendments can be made in the current laws to regulate fashion more extensively.
Send us your queries and we'll get back to you.
Let's Talk